0402210271
DETROIT FREE PRESS
040222
Sunday, February 22, 2004
METRO FINAL
1G
MITCH ALBOM Free Press columnist
Copyright (c) 2004, Detroit Free Press
THE SON MUST REFUTE FATHER'S HATEFUL RANTS
My sister married a wonderful guy. His father was a Hungarian Jew. During
World War II, he and his eight brothers and sisters were imprisoned in Nazi
concentration camps. Some were killed in gas chambers. Others were put on a
boat that was deliberately sunk.
By the war's end, my brother-in-law's father was the only one left. For years,
his wife would find bread stuffed under his pillow, a habit from Nazi
starvation.
Every now and then some nut case says the Holocaust was faked. Usually, you
dismiss him as pathetic.
Last week, however, a man named Hutton Gibson told a national radio host that
the Holocaust never happened, that there were no concentration camps, only
"work camps," and that Jews basically made the whole thing up.
Hutton Gibson is Mel Gibson's father.
So this nut case must be addressed.
From Auschwitz to Brooklyn?
He must be addressed because his son has made a movie called "The Passion of
the Christ" depicting Jesus' last hours. There are fears the movie will stoke
anti-Semitism. I have not seen the film yet -- it opens this week -- so I can
pass no judgment on it. But I have heard his father. And he needs no movie to
spew hatred.
Jews "are after one world religion and one world government" Hutton Gibson
declared. He said Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, who is Jewish,
should be hung. He said Holocaust museums were "a gimmick to collect money."
In fact, he called the entire Holocaust "fiction." He said Jews weren't
killed, "they simply got up and left! They were all over the Bronx and
Brooklyn and Sydney and Los Angeles. They have to . . . go where's there's
money."
That would be news to my brother-in-law's aunt, another Holocaust survivor
who, thanks to Nazi experiments, was left sterile, unable to have children.
She still bears a Nazi number burned into her arm.
I suppose Hutton Gibson would call that "a tattoo she got in the Bronx."
Now the elder Gibson is not new to this stuff. He writes books and magazine
articles denying the Holocaust and scorching the Jewish faith.
And I am not saying Mel Gibson believes what his father does.
But he needs to say so himself.
A time for action
Instead, to date, Gibson has refused to fully refute his father. He
acknowledges the Holocaust, but says, "Nothing can drive a wedge between me
and my blood. He's my father. I love him."
That's fine. But denying hatred does not cancel love. By his own doing, Gibson
has put himself on a stage where he has new obligations. He's not promoting a
"Lethal Weapon" movie here, where he's a crazed cop who swears and drinks and
sleeps with women (all pretty non-Christian stuff, by the way).
No. He has made a deeply religious movie, a lightning rod for Christians and
Jews, one he claims was inspired by his faith, including "going back to the
things I was raised with."
One presumes his father did some of that raising.
Mel Gibson insists he is not anti-Semitic. He can prove it by declaring his
father's words are wrong. How would Gibson feel if his father had been gassed,
shot or hung in Auschwitz or Dachau, instead of his luckier fate, enjoying a
good, long life hurling insults at others?
The reason Nazism existed is because people lived in denial. If you visit the
site of concentration camps today, you will be astounded by how close
neighborhoods were to the gates. Yet no one did anything -- even as innocent
people were murdered a stone's throw away.
No one asked Mel Gibson to become a spokesman on faith. He did that himself.
Now that he has hopped on center stage, he can't simply hear what he wants. He
has an obligation to publicly shoot down his father's words.
After all, Gibson said he made his movie because he could no longer deny his
faith. Imagine someone denying your existence.
Contact MITCH ALBOM at 313-223-4581 or albom@freepress.com.
THIS ELECTRONIC VERSION MAY DIFFER SLIGHTLY FROM THE PRINTED ARTICLE.
COLUMN